No person shall engage in the practice of medicine, either in
person or remotely using information transmitted electronically or through
other means, on a patient within the state of Tennessee unless duly licensed by
the Board in accordance with the provisions of the current statutes and rules.
Unless specifically set out in this rule, this rule is not intended to and does
not supersede any pre-existing federal or state statutes or rules and is not
meant to alter or amend the applicable standard of care in any particular field
of medicine or to amend any requirement for the establishment of a
physician-patient relationship.
(1)
Definitions -
(a) Facilitator - The
facilitator is an individual often affiliated with a local system of care or a
parent or legal guardian of the patient. The facilitator must be physically
present with the patient and is responsible for verifying the identity and
location of the patient and for the origination, collection and transmission of
data in the form of images or clinical data to the physician performing the
evaluation remotely.
(b) Medical
interpretation - The performance of a medical interpretation by a physician is
the rendering of a diagnosis regarding a particular patient by examination of
radiologic imaging studies, tissue specimens, bodily fluid specimens
(including, but not limited to urine, blood and cerebrospinal fluid) or medical
records requested by another physician or licensed health care
provider.
(c) Patient encounter -
The rendering of a documented medical opinion concerning evaluation, diagnosis,
and/or treatment of a patient whether the physician is physically present in
the same room, in a remote location within the state or across state
lines.
(d) Physician-patient
relationship - A physician-patient relationship exists when a physician serves
a patient's medical needs whether or not there has been an encounter in person
between the physician and patient.
(e) Research hospital - A hospital at which
fifty percent (50%) or more of the inpatients treated during the previous
calendar year were treated pursuant to research protocols.
(f) Store-and-forward technology - The use of
asynchronous electronic communications between a patient and healthcare
services provider at a distant site for the purpose of diagnostic and
therapeutic assistance in the care of patients and includes the transferring of
medical data from one site to another through the use of a device that records
or stores images that are sent or forwarded via electronic communication to
another site for consultation.
(g)
Telemedicine - Telemedicine is the practice of medicine using electronic
communication, information technology or other means, between a licensee in one
location and a patient in another location. Telemedicine is not an audio only
telephone conversation, email/instant messaging conversation or fax. It
typically involves the application of secure video conferencing or
store-and-forward to provide or support healthcare delivery by replicating the
interaction of a traditional encounter between a provider and a
patient.
(2)
Telemedicine Licenses Issued Under Previous Rule - As of the effective date of
this rule, the Board will no longer issue what was previously termed a
"telemedicine license." Individuals previously granted a telemedicine license
under the former version of this rule may apply to have the license converted
to a full license. Such individuals must complete the application for a full
license and provide all necessary documentation, though no new application fee
will be required as long as application is made within two years of the
effective date of this rule. Individuals who do not convert to a full license
(or do not qualify for full licensure) will retain the telemedicine license
subject to the following conditions:
(a) The
license must be timely renewed on a biennial basis, as required pursuant to
Rule
0880-02-.09. Notwithstanding
Rule
0880-02-.09, however, licenses
not timely renewed will not be subject to re-instatement and affected
individuals wishing to engage in the practice of medicine on patients located
in Tennessee will be required to make application for a full license, including
payment of the application fee.
(b)
Telemedicine license holders must maintain current ABMS specialty
board-certification. Licensees who do not maintain ABMS specialty
board-certification will not be entitled to renewal of the license.
(c) Licensees retaining a telemedicine
license are limited to the provision of medical interpretation services in the
area of their specialty board-certification. Such license holders do not
possess prescriptive authority in Tennessee.
(d) All telemedicine licenses are subject to
discipline for the same causes and pursuant to the same procedures as active,
unrestricted licenses.
(3) Effect of License - The issuance by the
Board of a license to practice medicine subjects the licensee to the
jurisdiction of the Board in all matters set forth in the Medical Practice Act
and implementing rules and regulations, including all matters related to
discipline. The licensee agrees by acceptance of such license to produce
patient medical records and materials as requested by the Board and to appear
before the Board upon receipt of notice from the Board commanding such
appearance. Failure of the licensee to appear and/or to produce records or
materials as requested, after appropriate notice, shall constitute grounds to
suspend or revoke the license at the Board's discretion.
(4) Exempted from the provisions of these
rules are the following:
(a) Licensed
physicians of other states when called in consultation regarding specific
clinical or scientific aspects of the field of medicine by a Tennessee
licensed/registered physician as provided by T.C.A. §
63-6-204(a)(3);
(b) US Military physicians operating within
the Federal jurisdiction and regulations related to their duties as provided by
T.C.A. §
63-6-204(a)(3);
(c) The informal practice of medicine between
physicians in the form of uncompensated professional dialogue regarding aspects
of the field of medicine; and
(d) A
recognized, highly specialized, licensed physician from another state or
country who specializes in the diagnosis and/or treatment of rare or orphan
diseases and who provides consultation to research hospitals, with or without
compensation or the expectation of compensation.
(5) Physicians who are contractually
obligated to provide and/or deliver medical services in Tennessee must be
licensed to practice medicine in Tennessee, regardless of whether such services
are in exchange for direct compensation.
(6) Notwithstanding the requirements of Rule
0880-02-.14(7),
a physician licensed in Tennessee may engage in the practice of telemedicine
under the following circumstances:
(a) Except
as provided under paragraphs seven (7) and eight (8) of this rule, the patient
encounter to establish or maintain the physician-patient relationship via
telemedicine between the physician in a remote location and the patient in
Tennessee may occur with or without the use of a facilitator so long as such
encounter is consistent with parts 1 and 2 of this Rule:
1. If no facilitator is present:
(i) The patient must utilize adequately
sophisticated technology to enable the remote provider to verify the patient's
identity and location with an appropriate level of confidence; and
(ii) The patient must transmit all relevant
health information at the level of store-and-forward technology or secure video
conferencing; and
(iii) The remote
provider must disclose his or her name, current and primary practice location,
medical degree and recognized specialty area, if any, and in accordance with
T.C.A. §
63-1-109.
2. If a facilitator is present:
(i) The facilitator must personally verify
the identity of the patient; however, all relevant health information must be
transmitted to the remote provider using at least the level of
store-and-forward technology. The facilitator and the patient may interact with
the provider at the remote location via secure video conferencing or
store-and-forward technology; and
(ii) The facilitator must identify
themselves, their role, and their title to the patient and the remote
physician; and
(iii) The remote
provider must disclose his or her name, current and primary practice location,
medical degree and recognized specialty area, if any, and all additional
information required pursuant to T.C.A. §
63-1-109.
(b) For patient encounters
conducted via telemedicine, the physician should have appropriate patient
record(s) or be able to obtain such information during the telemedicine
encounter.
(c) The physician
engaging in telemedicine is responsible for ensuring that the medical record
contains all pertinent data and information gleaned from the encounter. Any
physician conducting a patient encounter via telemedicine must so document in
the patient record and must state the technology used. All records for
Tennessee patients are subject to inspection pursuant to T.C.A. §
63-1-117.
(d) If the information transmitted through
electronic or other means as part of a patient's encounter is not of sufficient
quality or does not contain adequate information for the physician to form an
opinion, the physician must declare they cannot form an opinion to make an
adequate diagnosis and must request direct referral for inspection and actual
physical examination, request additional data, or recommend the patient be
evaluated by the patient's primary physician or other local health care
provider.
(7) A
physician licensed by the Board may, if requested to do so by another physician
licensed by the Board, engage in medical interpretation as defined in these
rules and render an opinion based on data which is transmitted electronically.
In such cases, the physician providing the medical interpretation need not
examine the patient and need not have the complete medical record accessible,
unless the interpreting physician believes that additional information is
necessary. Any opinion rendered by such interpreting physician must be reduced
to writing which includes the name and electronic signature of the interpreting
physician.
(8) No patient seeking
care via telemedicine who is under the age of eighteen (18) years of age can be
treated unless there is a facilitator present, except as otherwise authorized
by law.